Skip to content
First Front Door

One buyer, one house, three answers

Sam has a $72,000 deposit and an offer accepted at $720,000. Three lenders look at exactly the same application and reach three different conclusions. Here is why, in numbers.

These three lenders are invented

Lender A, B and C are not real companies and these are not real products. What is real is the kind of thing they differ on — how much overtime counts as income, and whose valuation the loan is measured against.

What Sam is working with

  • $720,000 — the price on the contract.
  • $72,000 — the deposit, saved. That is 10% of the price.
  • $648,000 — what is left to borrow.
  • $95,000 base salary, plus about $18,000 a year in regular overtime.

Sam has done the arithmetic everyone does: a 10% deposit, so a 90% loan.

The three answers

Three invented lenders, their overtime policy, their valuation, the resulting loan-to-value ratio and the outcome
Lender Overtime counted Their valuation LVR Answer
Lender A 50% of it $720,000 90% No — unless $103,000 more cash appears
Lender B 100% of it $690,000 93.9% No — unless $27,000 more cash appears
Lender C 100% of it $720,000 90% Yes

Lender A says no, and it is about overtime

Before a lender decides anything else, it has to satisfy itself you can afford the repayments. The first step is working out what income it is prepared to count — and that figure, not what you are actually paid, is what the loan is measured against.

Lender A counts 50% of overtime, because overtime can stop. So for Sam it does this:

$95,000 base + 50% of $18,000 overtime = $104,000

$104,000, not the $113,000 Sam is paid. On that income Lender A will lend up to $545,000:

$648,000 needed − $545,000 on offer = $103,000 missing

Lender A would write this loan if Sam put in $175,000 instead of $72,000. That is not a gap anybody closes by finding a bit more; it is a different purchase, a few years away.

Nothing is wrong with the application. It does not fit this lender's rule about this kind of income. Walk out of that branch believing you cannot buy and the mistake is not the lender's.

Lender B also says no, and it is about the house

Lender B counts the overtime in full. So unlike Lender A, it has no doubt Sam can afford the repayments — it assesses the full $113,000 and the income question is settled.

Its problem is the house. Lender B sends a valuer, and the valuer comes back at $690,000 — $30,000 less than Sam agreed to pay for it. In Lender B's view Sam is paying over the odds, and it will not lend against a price it does not believe.

A lender lends a percentage of its own valuation, not of your contract price, and Lender B stops at 90%. So the most it will put up is:

$690,000 valuation × 90% = $621,000

But Sam still has to pay the seller $720,000, and has $72,000 saved, so $648,000 has to come from somewhere:

$648,000 needed − $621,000 on offer = $27,000 missing

The lender will not cover that gap — covering it is the whole thing it just declined to do. It has to come from Sam, in cash, on top of the deposit already saved, taking it from $72,000 to $99,000. The house has not changed and Sam’s savings have not changed. One valuer’s opinion did.

Both lenders have now declined the purchase Sam is actually trying to make, and the only thing separating them is how far away the number is. $27,000 is a hard phone call to a family member. $103,000 is not a phone call at all.

Lender C says yes

Lender C counts the overtime in full and its valuer comes back at the contract price, so the security is $720,000 and the LVR is 90% — the number Sam expected. $648,000 is inside what it will lend. It is above 80%, so there is mortgage insurance to pay either way; what that costs and who it protects.

What John actually did

John is a mortgage broker, and his job is to know these three lenders’ rules before any of them are asked: which one halves overtime, which one’s valuers have been coming in under on that kind of apartment, how far each will lend against its own valuation, and what each of them charges once you are in. Then to work out which of them fits Sam — not just which will say yes, but on what rate, what fees and what terms.

So he did not send it to Lender A, because he knew what it does with overtime. He did not send it to Lender B, because he knew about the valuations. He sent one application, to Lender C, and it was approved.

That is the work, and it is invisible from outside: it happens before an application is lodged, and what it produces is the absence of a problem.

Three lenders is the simple version

A real panel is dozens of lenders, and a lender is not one set of rules. Each has several products, and the rules move between products at the same lender: one will go to a higher LVR if mortgage insurance is added, one treats self-employed income differently, one has a policy for your profession, one will not touch the type of apartment you are looking at. The same application can be a yes under one of a lender’s products and a no under another.

So it is not three answers. It is dozens of lenders times several products each, every combination with its own income rules, its own LVR ceiling, its own valuer and its own rate — and the right one for you is not the same as the right one for the person ahead of you in the queue.

Nobody works through that by visiting branches one at a time, which is the practical reason the job exists. What a broker does, and who pays them.

What to take from this

  • A decline is about one lender’s rules, not about whether you can buy a house.
  • Your deposit does not fix your LVR. The valuation does. Ask early which valuation a lender will use and what happens if it comes in low.
  • Ask how your income is treated before you apply, in those words. Regular overtime, bonuses, commission, casual hours and self-employment can all be counted differently.
  • A valuation shortfall is paid in cash. It cannot be added to the loan, because the loan is the thing that is too big.

These three lenders, their policies and their valuations are invented to show how the arithmetic works. They are not offers, not products and not a prediction about any real lender. General information only — not financial, credit, legal or tax advice, and not tailored to your circumstances. First Front Door holds no Australian credit licence.